====== Incentivized technologies not pursued ====== This is a collection of cases where someone seemingly had a large incentive to pursue a technology, and did not. ===== Lists ===== ==== 'Resisted technological temptations' ==== These are cases where incentives to pursue a technology were overcome by concerns about downsides not imminently accruing to the decision-maker (e.g. risks to distant people, ethical concerns). These cases are being collected via the [[responses_to_ai:technological_inevitability:incentivized_technologies_not_pursued:resisted_technological_temptations_project|Resisted Technological Temptations Project]]. === Investigated cases === ^ Technology ^ Key Actors ^ Value Resisted ^ Time Period ^ Explanation ^ | [[responses_to_ai:technological_inevitability:incentivized_technologies_not_pursued:geoengineering|Geoengineering]] | Global Organizations, Large Countries | \$1012-1013/yr by mid-century | 1974((Geoengineering proposed.)) / 2006((Scientific taboo broken.)) to Present | Scientists' and environmental groups' opposition inhibit experiments needed before implementation | | [[responses_to_ai:technological_inevitability:incentivized_technologies_not_pursued:nuclear_power|Nuclear power]] | Some Countries | \$109-1010/yr and 103-104 lives/yr | 1964((Bodega Bay Power Plant canceled in US.)) / 1987((Italian nuclear referendum.)) / 2011((Germany decides to shut down nuclear power plants.)) to Present | Political decisions important; local opposition grows to national movement; warning shots | | [[responses_to_ai:technological_inevitability:incentivized_technologies_not_pursued:vaccine_challenge_trials|Vaccine challenge trials]] | Pharmaceutical Companies, IRBs | \$1012-1013 and 105-106 lives lost for COVID-19 | 1974((National Research Act created IRBs)) to Present | Asymmetric justice for IRBs slows medical research | === Plausible cases === This is a non-exhaustive list of plausible cases that we have not investigated. * Chlorofluorocarbons, many actors, 1985-present * Nanotechnology, scientists and governments, five decades ago to present * Airships / Zeppelins * Genetic engineering of humans * Some scientific studies prevented by the burden of IRB / GDPR compliance * Recreational drug development * Dietary restrictions, in most (all?) human cultures * GMOs, in some countries * Use of nuclear explosions in construction * Fracking, in some countries * Various weapons (nuclear, chemical, biological, land mines, etc), in some countries and at some times ==== Other notable failures of selfish expected value maximization in pursuing technologies ==== === Plausible cases === (We have not investigated these cases) * AI winters * Delay in nuclear weapons research early in WWII * Excalibur